What do your members really want?

Image generated by AI

The question every membership leader is asking in 2025.

The number of members you have looks consistent. Renewal rates are stable. But something feels different.

Members aren't engaging the way they used to. They're not downloading reports with the same enthusiasm. Event attendance is patchy. And when you ask what they value most, the answers aren't what you expected.

Here's what might be happening: your members' needs have evolved faster than your membership offer.

Member expectations could be changing

We're witnessing a fundamental change in what individuals expect from membership organisations. It's not just about access to information anymore—that's increasingly available elsewhere, often for free. Members are looking for something deeper, more meaningful, and more transformational.

The challenge? Some membership organisations are still operating like content libraries when their members want to be part of something that actually changes their member-led lives.

This shift has prompted us to develop what we call the Membership Value Pyramid—a framework that maps the evolution from basic transactional benefits to the transformational experiences that create lasting member loyalty.

The three worlds of membership value

Membership Value Pyramid: The strategic shift from transactional to transformational offerings

Think of membership value like a pyramid with three distinct levels. Some organisations live almost entirely at the base, whilst the most successful and ambitious ones have learned to guide their members toward the peak.

At the bottom: Transactional value

This is where most membership organisations start—and some get stuck. You should already be familiar with this level: access to reports and databases, member discounts, newsletters, content libraries, basic helpline services.

However, these benefits are increasingly easy to replicate. AI can generate reports, discount codes are everywhere, and free content abounds.

If this is all you're offering, you're competing in a commoditised market where members will likely leave for something cheaper or free.

In the middle: Relational value

This is where genuine differentiation begins. It's about peer networking and community building and interactive events that actually matter helping to create a shared sense of member identity.

The key difference? Members don't just consume at this level—they contribute and belong. It's harder to replicate and infinitely more valuable to experience. This is where members start saying "I value the connections I've made" rather than "I read your reports."

At the peak: Transformational value

This is the pinnacle of membership value—where your organisation becomes integral to who your members become, not just what they know.

We're talking about career progression and leadership development, professional recognition that opens doors, advocacy opportunities that give members industry influence, and personal growth that creates lasting value.

This value is deeply personal and irreplaceable. It transforms not just what members know, but who they are in their professional world.

What this looks like in the real world

Below we have given some examples of where some organisations may sit within the Pyramid:

Association A

Offers annual reports, industry newsletters, and member discounts. Their renewal rate hovers around 65%. Members consistently say "I can get this information elsewhere" and view membership as a subscription service—easily cancelled when budgets tighten.

Association B

Provides all of that, plus active networking groups, events, training, and peer mentoring. Their renewal rate is 82%. Members say "I value the connections I've made" and view membership as joining a professional community—much harder to leave.

Association C

delivers comprehensive value across all levels, with clear pathways for career advancement, industry recognition, and leadership roles within the profession. Their renewal rate is 94%. Members say "This organisation shaped my career" and view membership as integral to their professional identity—almost irreplaceable.

The difference isn't just in renewal rates—it's in member advocacy and engagement. Association C's members don't just renew; they refer colleagues and actively promote the organisation.

Why this matters

The acceleration of AI and digital transformation has made basic membership benefits increasingly vulnerable. Information that once required expensive research can now be generated instantly. Industry insights that were exclusive are now widely available.

But human connection, community belonging, and transformational growth? These remain uniquely valuable because they're uniquely human.

The strategic imperative is clear: move up the pyramid or risk being displaced by free alternatives.

The technology that makes transformation possible

Here's where it gets interesting. Moving up the pyramid isn't just about offering new benefits—it requires sophisticated understanding of your members and the ability to personalise their journey.

This is where modern CRM platforms become essential. sheepCRM enables membership organisations to segment members, for instance by career stage and interests, automate personalised journeys that guide members toward higher-value experiences, and track actual transformation rather than just participation.

The technology doesn't replace human relationship building—it amplifies it by ensuring the right members connect at the right moments with the right opportunities.

It's the difference between hoping good things happen and creating and guiding them strategically.

The path forward

Most organisations have the foundation for transformation already in place. The question isn't whether you can move up the pyramid—it's whether you're willing to shift focus from what you provide to what gives members value.

Start by honestly assessing where your organisation currently sits. Most benefits likely cluster around basic access and information, with some community elements. That's normal—and it represents massive opportunity.

The next step is strengthening peer connections within existing offerings. Use your CRM to identify natural affinity groups and facilitate introductions. Create clear routes from new member to community contributor to industry leader. Make these pathways visible and achievable.

Most importantly, start measuring transformation, not just participation. Track career advancements, leadership roles, and member achievements—not just event attendance and download counts.

Access the white paper

The Membership Value Pyramid is just one framework from our comprehensive research into how membership organisations can thrive in the AI era. The full methodology includes detailed strategies for moving up each tier, the specific role of AI in enhancing human connection, and a complete action plan for membership leaders.

Download the complete white paper to access the full framework, implementation guidance, and strategic insights that can transform your membership offer from subscription service to career catalyst.

Already read our white paper?

If you're ready to assess where your organisation sits on the pyramid and explore how to climb higher, book a discovery call with our team.

We'll help you map your current position, identify quick wins, and develop a strategy for creating truly transformational member value.

Book a call with one our experts to start your transformation today.